Crossings
Anyone who has crossed a busy road in a metropolis without well-regulated traffic, such as Mumbai, India, can understand the plight of a deer trying to cross a two-lane highway in rural United States. Evolution has not prepared deer for encounters with automobiles. Over one million crashes between vehicles and large mammals, like deer, occur annually in the U.S. alone, with wildlife often ending up as roadkill. Roads and fast-moving vehicles give humans mobility. Ironically, for thousands of wildlife species worldwide, ranging from butterflies to elephants, the same pathways act as barriers, severing some animals from their seasonal migration routes.
In Crossings, Ben Goldfarb, an environmental journalist, takes us on an eye-opening road trip across continents to show how paved roads, long seen as markers of civilization, disrupt the natural world. Mostly, he travels with researchers in road ecology, a relatively new discipline that studies “how life change(s) for plants and animals with a road and traffic nearby.” If roads are a disease, the author suggests, wildlife crossings (a network of tunnels, overpasses, and bridge-like structures that allow animals safe passage) could be the treatment. Design matters, however. On the expanded Trans-Canada Highway in Banff National Park, underpasses helped cut elk fatalities, while grizzly bears fared much better with the park’s overpasses.
Goldfarb argues that practicing road ecology is a moral mandate, whether the goal is saving species from extinction or protecting more common ones. Even roadkill, he suggests, can be managed to serve ecology. Deer, the most common roadkill, feed scavenging birds, coyotes, and even humans. But scavenging has its own danger. Golden eagles of the American West, gorged on venison, take “about as long as a 747 to achieve liftoff,” and risk becoming roadkill themselves. A service that drags deer carcasses away from the road would let the eagles finish their meal in peace, the author writes.
Traffic itself can ravage wildlife that relies on keen hearing for survival. In one study, researchers replayed recordings of Glacier National Park’s iconic Going-to-the-Sun Road at a migratory bird stopover in Idaho. The road, celebrated as an engineering marvel and a crown jewel of American scenic drives, became, in this experiment, a “phantom road.” Even without cars or predators present, the noise alone unsettled the birds. Some species avoided the area entirely. Others, unable to distinguish safety from threat, defaulted to vigilance: they scanned the skies as if hawks might be near. That constant watchfulness drained their energy, leaving them too exhausted to forage. Many starved. The paradox is striking: a road revered by humans for its beauty can, at the same time, devastate the creatures whose survival depends on silence.
Road ecology has yielded many other insights supporting the view that “roads warp earth in every way and at every scale.” And more roads are coming: two billion motorized vehicles, including self-driving cars, are projected to be on the road by 2030, twice as many as in 2010.
What can be done? In the US, initiatives are underway to dismantle abandoned forest roads and protect animal migratory routes. Biodiverse Brazil, though a developing country, now builds new highways with wildlife crossings, and the law requires highway operators to gather roadkill data and transport injured animals to veterinary clinics.
With technology and thoughtfulness, it may be possible to mitigate the worst effects of roads. Small, human-scale efforts offer encouragement too: people in Tasmania care for orphaned wallabies and other marsupials whose mothers were killed on the road, and volunteers in Alaska deliver moose roadkill to hungry families.
Still, the scale of the problem demands more than kindness. “Individual drivers can’t make roads lie lighter on earth, any more than people swapping out light bulbs to solve climate change,” Goldfarb writes wryly, making clear that the response must be a colossal, planet-wide effort. Beautifully written, Crossings tells hard truths about roads, automobiles, and life on the planet, yet leaves us feeling that the damage can still be undone.
Another review in Science, not mine.
